I've started a tiny subsection of contemporary genre fiction I like to think of as Future Classics*. "The Last House on Needless Street" just made the list. All the things in the blurb (the one on Goodreads, at least) are true and I was still pleasantly surprised.
* It's a very short list:
Josh Malerman - Birdbox (his only book I enjoyed. It has been diminishing returns since then to the point of unreadability)
Paul Tremblay - A Head Full of Ghosts
Grady Hendrix - My Best Friend's Exorcism
Alma Katsu - The Hunger (You loved "Terror"? You'll love this too then)
Marisha Pessl - Night Film
Elizabeth Kostova - The Historian
I've also bought a couple of inscribed books directly from Philip Fracassi. "Beneath a Pale Sky" was neat. Iain Reid also makes the list but I haven't decided which book.