FWIW - I've been a long time Koontz reader (I hesitate to say "fan" because, whilst I enjoy his books, I'm nowhere near as passionate about them as I am about Kings works) .. The first one I read was a PB Shadowfires under the Leigh Nichols pseudonym (hadn't heard of Kootz at that time) .. Since then (and that'd have to have been around 20 years ago - maybe more) I've picked up all the trade HC releases, and have enjoyed them for what they are (some more so than others, for sure). I have a couple of the Charnel House L/E's (mainly cos they were fairly well priced on the secondary market and are really beautiful productions, and a couple of flat signed as well (pick up mostly by accident rather design). Basically, in terms of the criticisms levelled at his body of work, all I can say is that it's horses for courses, millions love his stuff, just as many don't, and I imagine the same is true about any other author you care to mention (although, of course, the numbers of fans/detractors vary significantly)