This has been touched on in a number of threads a few times. I think minor arguments or large disagreements have started as well because of it.
I'd like this thread to be used to discuss who you thought they were. For example, imo, Marten is a twinner of Walter. Also, I believe that Eddie is the twin of Cuthbert. For me, they aren't twinners (like Sloat and Morgan) because they are not living at the same time.
Now some people think that Eddie is Cuthbert's reincarnation. I disagree and I think that it is a different occurrence entirely.
So, I know we are getting into semi-existentialism and such but I thought this could be the place for it.
What do you guys think? Also, why?
Let the discussion begin!