I was thinking the same thing Jean. I was going to suggest the writing as the other point, but then considering they're all written by the same author, I wasn't sure if that made sense to anyone but...
Type: Posts; User: Heather19
I was thinking the same thing Jean. I was going to suggest the writing as the other point, but then considering they're all written by the same author, I wasn't sure if that made sense to anyone but...
Just my thoughts, but maybe for the final round instead of re-read, which would you rather read, or maybe even do you like better? We're pitting two books against each other right? I know in the...
Personally I'd vote for a straight ranking. I think its the fairest way for the best to move on.
My personal choice would be a straight 1-30 ranking. It's definitely fairer. What if King has a bad era, and those books move on when there's without a doubt better works by him? I think it...
Personally I like that :)
Thanks for putting this together. You've got my opinions here already, so I don't think I need to restate them. I just think they need to be rewritten maybe? All three are important aspects of a...
That's why I want next time to try excluding the DT books from CRA, and maybe have a DT CRA separately. I'll start a thread tomorrow where we will discuss all possible variations and ways to enhance...
So give it an A if you like the characters or C if you disliked? I don't think a book has to have character development to have strong characters.
Absolutely. I have been saying the same since the start of this round; maybe our voting experience has accumulated in years, and now it's time for some changes. I will collect all observations to the...
Re: The Gunslinger grading in Round 2 (replying to Jean's grading it as AAA)
Hmmm, but if you didn't like it...
I think we need a better grading system. I can't give a book I didn't like an A...