Search:

I voted Books 7, 6 & 5 as my top 3.

Yeah - that news was a killer. :pullhair:

No Letti - never insane!
*hey, youse guys with the white jackets, get in here quick while i keep her distracted*
ahem....

:lol: No, I know what you mean. But that's almost like you're a medium...

It's a good question Letti.
I'm tempted to use the old "If it's not in the Book - it's not cannon" argument.... but honestly I think that the Author 'owns' the work in it's entirity, so if (s)he...

OK Dark - I see what you mean.
I would not be overly aware of these Fundamentalists you speak of, but I get the gist of it.
Yes, you are right in saying that it's largely irrelevant to the story...

I agree - I think JKR was aware of the reaction her announcement would get, but I don't believe that's why she chose to divulge the information.

As I said before, she's got this book of...

Absolutely correct Letti - there's no way JKR just let this slip out innocently.
And yes, I did read Sarajean's comment:

... but it was such a deliberate answer - such a deliberate statement ......

Thanks Maer, that was a great link.
Gotta agree with pretty much everything the man said!

Beg to differ Jean, Lockhart's books were proven to total works of fiction!:lol:

/Excuse my light treatment of a serious debate.:evil:

Tonks rocks!
That's a very good image - talented.

Snap! - also did a total re-read this year.
Only problem is that I'll have to fight my 12-yr-old for firsties on it // or splash out and buy 2 copies :)