Search:

Type: Posts; User: ManOfWesternesse

Search: Search took 0.02 seconds.

  1. Replies
    350
    Views
    119,463

    Sticky: Poll: The one where he whispers "19" is the revised.

    The one where he whispers "19" is the revised.
  2. Replies
    350
    Views
    119,463

    Sticky: Poll: :lol: I half-agree with you, but then remind...

    It wasn't.[/QUOTE]
    :lol:
    I half-agree with you, but then remind myself that SK wrote it, so like it or not it has to be valid.
    Anyway, I've read the Revised more than once (ie. twice:dance:) so...
  3. Replies
    350
    Views
    119,463

    Sticky: Poll: I too prefer the original, but my advice is to...

    I too prefer the original, but my advice is to give her the revised.
    Should she go on to become a fan, then she'll still appreciate the original on the inevitable re-read.
  4. Replies
    350
    Views
    119,463

    Sticky: Poll: Roland did not know this one by name. He saw it...

    Roland did not know this one by name. He saw it in the distance and it ran off when he called to it.
    About Callahan - I've a feeling you are right but don't recall it well. ?
  5. Replies
    350
    Views
    119,463

    Sticky: Poll: Agree with all that Brainslinger, and at the end...

    Agree with all that Brainslinger, and at the end of the day I'm happy with either one in a re-read (with probably a slight personal preference for the Original).
  6. Replies
    350
    Views
    119,463

    Sticky: Poll: I agree also - for me the revised is...

    I agree. I was playing the devil's advocate a bit because it is such a subejct of contention.[/QUOTE]

    I agree also - for me the revised is too....pointed in places. eg. no need for a sneak preview...
  7. Replies
    350
    Views
    119,463

    Sticky: Poll: Yes there are! I've started a DT re-read, and...

    One thing is sure, there are a great deal of them.[/QUOTE]

    Yes there are!
    I've started a DT re-read, and I'm reading the original but cross-checking with the revised now & again (just in places...
  8. Replies
    350
    Views
    119,463

    Sticky: Poll: If I had to choose - then the Original.

    If I had to choose - then the Original.
Results 1 to 8 of 8