Search:

64% v 54% Interesting. It is starting to even out a bit, if I remember correctly. :)

Well, you actually didn't answer the question. ;)
The thread is....
If you HAD to choose. There are many reasons to like one over the other or to ignore one or treat them as two different stories...

Yeah, they cannot get that feeling we did. When you didn't know anything about anything. I mean the original one has much more mysteries and secrets somehow. It's like being a fog.. That's why I love...

Letti, I'd be willing to bet that those people who started the series reading the revised and then at a later date picked up the original version ALL voted that the Revised is their preference. ...

Though I agree with your vote for revised....you DEFINITELY should read the original version.

I agree Ruthful.
I am listening to the original right now and I keep having the same thoughts. It totally sounds/reads like a teenager wrote it. I'm not saying that it is bad but I do agree that...

Purists schmurists. :D
Revised! :)

Elusive? :unsure:
I just saw about a dozen copies of it at Half Priced Books, for about a buck fifty. Also, I see it in mass market paperback and trade paperback on eBay all the time for very cheap.

That's what I'm saying dude...get the original. All hard-core junkies should have both. :D

(not a fan of .net either)

I'm fairly certain it has been covered in this thread. :)
I seem to remember anyway...
IMO, they are so small and rather insignificant that they don't merit detailed descriptions. Why don't you...

Oh phooey! The revised is fine....I read it from your own post above! :P
Even though I prefer it, I would agree with what you said about not touching the magic of the original.

I am betting he won't revise them either.

Well said CK. Truly. :thumbsup:

I never had any complaints about someone wanting to revise their work. It also helps that I consider the Revised as more of a Dark Tower book 8 then I see it as a replacement to Dark Tower book 1. ...

Thanks for the info Brice! :)
I have a saved search on eBay to try and find them.

so would i monte! no offense to guidall, but i prefer muller. guidall does a nice job finishing up the series though.[/QUOTE]

I have fallen into CK's way of thinking. They both do a great job! ...

If I had to choose between the original or revised audiobook, I would choose Muller's original over Guidall's revised. :)

I like to think of The Dark Tower books as a loop. I start with the original Gunslinger and I read the series through and after DT7, I pick up the revised edition and read that through. It is an...

I've looked for the King readings on eBay before with no luck. I'll have to look for the Muller reading of DT1 there...
Thanks for the info, friends!

I want to hear the King version! So, there is no Muller recording of the original?