Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mattrick
I think now that I've finished playing the Bioshock Remasters (minus Infinite DLC) I'm going to write something on them. Infinite is definitely pretty underwhelming now. It's a good game, but it's just missing what made Bioshock 1/2 work so well, especially the horror and the tension of those games. Infinite is just a straight up shooter for the most part, and it plays well for that, but the game play is a far more hollow experience than the first two games. The two key elements they introduce, the skyline and the tears, are extremely underutilized. If it wasn't for the story and characters and the great art direction, it would be just a fun shooter.
It's the DLC that truly makes it a Bioshock Game so including the DLC is really good, but the core game is a good game that's a mediocre Bioshock title.
That wasn't all Ken Levine's fault though. He wanted more time to finish implementing and perfecting everything he wanted to do but 2K pretty much told him here's your deadline, meet it, end of story. He was forced to cut a lot of the shit he wanted to add.
And yeah Infinite with its vast blue skies was never going to match the tight corridor paranoia of the first Bioshock. They're different stories with different approaches. The art direction, dialogue, reality bending, mind bending sci-fi is what makes that game special. The DLC rounds out the entire universe and puts a pretty pink bow on it.