BTVSAT - Quarterfinals: 2000s (Bracket 2)

Lost
vs.
Six Feet Under

Previously on BTVSAT:

• Lost beat Sons of Anarchy and Carnivàle (139.16)
• Six Feet Under beat Boston Legal and Supernatural (115.42)

L O S T

6FU - one of the best series ever. Too bad it has to go up against Lost, which I like, but feel not even close in the same league.

Come on , more votes for LOST.

Oh man. Worst pairing ever. I absolutely love both. I seriously sat here and thought about this for 5 minutes.

Finally, though, I had to go with Six Feet Under.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Erin

Oh man. Worst pairing ever. I absolutely love both. I seriously sat here and thought about this for 5 minutes.

Finally, though, I had to go with Six Feet Under.

---

I love you! :couple:

Yes, a very tough pairing indeed. But series are no longer randomized, remember, so it's even out of chance's hands now - it's the points that count now...

:o

LOST!

Is it just me? I feel Lost is way overrated. I loved it as I watched it, but it never stayed with me past the actual viewing. Sure it was a fun ride, a very original series, but in the end, especially when compared to something earth-shatteringly deep as Six Feet Under, I dunno, it just pales, in my opinion.

Is it just me ? Or is Six Feet Under overrated ? :)

To answer your original question though - no, Lost is not overrated. If anything it's under appreciated. I've never felt a stronger emotional reaction to dilemmas presented on screen the way Lost handled it.

And what did Six Feet Under make you feel? Me, I cried during the series finale. During the Lost series finale I felt nothing.

It's probably my favorite ending of all time. Any medium.

Now you guys got me intrigued by all this finale talk. Makes me want to watch both series.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RainInSpain

Now you guys got me intrigued by all this finale talk. Makes me want to watch both series.

---

You haven't? What are you still doing here? Shoo!

Yeah, I'm that uncivilized :lol: But I intend to change that.

Lost is by no means near the quality of six feet under, as much as I love it. Six Feet Under is simply a masterpiece in television, something no show will come close to matching for a long, long time. I love Lost but Six Feet Under wins even in the finale department. Damn, did Six Feet Under wrap everything up in a way totally befitting of the shows main theme. Pure love for that show.

I'd be surprised if Six Feet Under managed to win here. Lost is one of those shows with a massive dedicated fanbase that raves its the greatest show ever made.

I went with Six Feet Under. As much as I like Lost, Six Feet Under honestly blows it out of the water.

I voted for the show that lies in the shadow of the statue. :evil:

You made the right choice, Ricardos.

6'\/

Oh man I love Six Feet Under, but it's Lost! How could I not vote for it :D

Easy. Select the right choice: Six Feet Under.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Heather19

Oh man I love Six Feet Under, but it's Lost! How could I not vote for it :D

---

:wub:

However it turns out, I am pretty proud of Six Feet Under holding te lead so far against a titan like Lost, even if by a narrow margin.

Feev, did you start watching Six Feet Under yet?

How this could even be close is a mystery that tops anything Lost did in it's entire run. Amazing.

:thumbsup: