I've no doubt the edition will be worth every penny, although I will pass on it, myself, as I'm trying to be laser-focused in my collecting goals.
The nice thing is that it looks like Jerad is taking a markedly different design approach to the material, when comparing to Paul's approach for Suntup. One could buy both and have two very different and wonderful editions. I don't think you can really ask, "Who did it better?", since the design goals are so distinct.
HBJ