2012 List
2013 List
2014 List
2015 List
2016 List

1. Blood Vow - JR Ward
2. Prince Lestat and the Realms of Atlantis - Anne Rice
3. Traitor's Blade - Sebastien de Castell
4. Feversong - Karen Marie Moning
5. Senlin Ascends - Josiah Bancroft
6. In Calabria - Peter S. Beagle
7. The Many Selves of Katherine North - Emma Geen
8. Smiler's Fair - Rebecca Levene
9. The Chosen - JR Ward
10. The Association - Bentley Little
11. Strange The Dreamer - Laini Taylor
12. Gwendy's Button Box - King/Chizmar
13. Swan Song - Robert McCammon
14. The Underground Railroad - Colson Whitehead
15. Haven - Tom Deady
16. Sleeping Beauties - Stephen & Owen King
17. I'll Bring You the Birds from Out of the Sky - Brian Hodge
18. This World is Full of Monsters - Jeff VanderMeer
19. Strange Weather - Joe Hill