I concur. The only two signatures that add to the book are from the artist, and the author. If a buyer wants Paul ( and others) to sign their personal copy and they are willing, that's great. Otherwise I say leave perfection alone.Originally Posted by webstar1000
YepI concur. The only two signatures that add to the book are from the artist, and the author. If a buyer wants Paul ( and others) to sign their personal copy and they are willing, that's great. Otherwise I say leave perfection alone.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
HELP ME FIND
Insomnia #459
ANY S/L #459
I think this conversation is about what constitutes an artist rather than who should sign. It seems everyone agrees only the artists involved should sign.
For example, if the person making the boards hand picks and scorches each one to get a specific look and feel, does that count as art? I agree that anything made with a repeatable process doesn't count, but it seems there are a number of hand made, unique components involved. The tradition is obviously artist = illustrator.
At the end of the day I don't feel strongly either way.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Wanted:
Michael Whelan & DT Original Art
Paul is the ultimate arbiter. I know on the copy I purchased, I want it exactly as described. What the other buyers want is between them and Paul, but at some point, every single person involved in the process can't sign the book (who cut down the tree, etc.).
I'm intrigued as to why these signatures would take away from the book? If the book had originally been announced with all the signatures being talked about, would that have been a deal killer?
I speak for myself having purchased one. Paul has obviously put quite a bit of thought into this project. "Too many cooks spoil in the kitchen spoil the broth" comes to mind.
I can't answer the hypothetical question myself, as the project has been announced, and I like it as it is.
I don't think everyone should sign.
Stephen Stroud should sign.
Any artisan can affix his trademark.
If buyers would like Paul's signature then they should ask him for it.
"One day you're going to figure out that everything they taught you was a lie."
I'm pretty sure I'm with Brian, but agree it's ultimately Paul's decision. Hell obviously make the right one
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Wanted:
Michael Whelan & DT Original Art
I'm personally going to open the box and have the mailman that delivers the package to me sign the book.
Just kidding, I'm good with whatever Paul wants to do. It's going to be awesome either way.
Looking for:
- Philtrum Press Eyes of the Dragon RED #165
- Fine Viking Eyes of the Dragon proof
It's worth pointing out that, were this a run-of-the-mill (woodworking pun not intended) copy of Firestarter, no one here would be interested in it at all - it is precisely the work of the craftsmen behind this edition's unique qualities that make it a subject of interest at all.
Eastasia has always taught college students to feel pride or shame according to their race.
This reminds me of something: I ordered a CD (a music album, not audio book etc.) from overseas (it was not widely available, not on Amazon etc.), and the mailing form on the box contained customs information, which required a signature. Turns out, the signature was that of the main guy (song writer/vocalist/guitarist) in the band - I basically have an artist's signature in the form of a simple piece of mail (yes, I saved the box).
Eastasia has always taught college students to feel pride or shame according to their race.
firemonkey66
"I'm personally going to open the box and have the man that delivers the package to me sign the book."
HEY... BUDDY! ARE YOU SURE YOU WANT ME TO SIGN THAT THING?
Spoiler:
That's pretty cool. Who was the musician?This reminds me of something: I ordered a CD (a music album, not audio book etc.) from overseas (it was not widely available, not on Amazon etc.), and the mailing form on the box contained customs information, which required a signature. Turns out, the signature was that of the main guy (song writer/vocalist/guitarist) in the band - I basically have an artist's signature in the form of a simple piece of mail (yes, I saved the box).
Since you asked, I will abuse the opportunity to plug the band:That's pretty cool. Who was the musician?This reminds me of something: I ordered a CD (a music album, not audio book etc.) from overseas (it was not widely available, not on Amazon etc.), and the mailing form on the box contained customs information, which required a signature. Turns out, the signature was that of the main guy (song writer/vocalist/guitarist) in the band - I basically have an artist's signature in the form of a simple piece of mail (yes, I saved the box).
The band is Traffic Experiment: http://www.trafficexperiment.net/
The musician is Stuart Chalmers.
The "sampler" video (which is quite good) for their only (as yet) full album (Blue Suburbia) is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHU0MTxd1Cs (go ahead, give the guys 3:22 of your time; this is a nice cross sample of the album's various moods and is set to some simple but evocative video). I think they call themselves "art rock," some call it prog, but I find it a bit more radio-friendly (not in a bad way) than much prog.
All of the songs from Blue Suburbia can be heard at: http://shop.trafficexperiment.net/album/blue-suburbia
Eastasia has always taught college students to feel pride or shame according to their race.
From the FB page : "The next three books are confirmed.... what could they be?"
>>> https://www.facebook.com/dragonrebou...23162271325033
Get your wallet ready between the CD books, the PS Publishing ones, those and potential others !
------------------------------------------------
CLUB STEPHEN KING (french website about STEPHEN KING, since 1992) : on : Facebook | Twitter | Instagram
------------------------------------------------
I did a pre-buy of the CD books so I am safe.. and cannot stand the PS ones so I am not buying them.. so I am safe
HELP ME FIND
Insomnia #459
ANY S/L #459
Yup but still have to order the portfolios per bookI did a pre-buy of the CD books so I am safe.. and cannot stand the PS ones so I am not buying them.. so I am safe
lol trueYup but still have to order the portfolios per bookI did a pre-buy of the CD books so I am safe.. and cannot stand the PS ones so I am not buying them.. so I am safe
HELP ME FIND
Insomnia #459
ANY S/L #459
Pretty exciting that the 2nd book is just going into production and we already know that there will be at least 3 more. This is going to be a hell of a set.
Looking for:
- Philtrum Press Eyes of the Dragon RED #165
- Fine Viking Eyes of the Dragon proof
Can't wait to see what they are! I just hope there's a little relief in between.
Yes, I'm hoping they are too!Can't wait to see what they are! I just hope there's a little relief in between.
Wanted: Human skin edition of The Book of the Dead. Will accept PC copy.
Can't wait to see what they are! I just hope there's a little relief in between.Yes, I'm hoping they are too!Can't wait to see what they are! I just hope there's a little relief in between.
I also hope there is a lot of relief between books. I am thrilled to be in on these books but if there are going to be multiple books each year I hope the price is more in line with the first book and doesn't grow exponentially with each book as it seems to have done with the second. I would be heartbroken to have to opt out.
I think Paul mentioned no more than 2 a year but I am sure he will chime in. The amount of work he has to put in... wouldnt be any sooner I am sure! haha
HELP ME FIND
Insomnia #459
ANY S/L #459
Right. I'm just lining up future titles. I don't think I will do more than 2 a year. As a collector myself, I can sympathize with not wanting to be hit every other month or so with a new book to buy. And there is so much time involved working on these anyway.
In terms of pricing, every book will be different based on the bindings. I've done my best to keep the costs down and not compromise on quality. Many designer bindings can cost in the thousands. So I have to find a happy balance there.
Anyway, breathe easy folks. I won't bombard you.
Count me among those that would be heartbroken if these books go north of 1k and I have to bow out. Maybe if it were once a year, but twice? I can't justify that to she who rolls her eyes.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
