Current Market Value-Experts assess yours, or other's collectible King item

[jhanic]

To me also.

John

[herbertwest]

It does look a bit faded, but IMO it still look like a nice copy to me. I just have lower standards

[at_one]

Right. That's what I was asking about....I'm aware of the fading, just curious how it would affect it's value?

[Mr. Rabbit Trick]

Right. That's what I was asking about....I'm aware of the fading, just curious how it would affect it's value?

I think you know the answer. Would you not be better waiting for a better copy?

[at_one]

Right. That's what I was asking about....I'm aware of the fading, just curious how it would affect it's value?

I think you know the answer. Would you not be better waiting for a better copy?

I'm pretty thrifty about my book buying....I wish I had $1,000's to throw around, but don't. There is 2 EotD out there right now.....this one is $150ish, the other $300. Just trying to get opinions to assist in my decision making.

[biomieg]

$150 for this one is too much (I'd say $75, max). A NF copy should be no more than $175-200. They come up for sale quite often, it's a pretty common proof. I'd wait for a better deal to come along.

[at_one]

$150 for this one is too much (I'd say $75, max). A NF copy should be no more than $175-200. They come up for sale quite often, it's a pretty common proof. I'd wait for a better deal to come along.

Awesome...That's great advice.....THANKS!

[biomieg]

To be honest, my estimates may be a little on the low side - I haven't kept up with recent sales. But I've seen several nice copies go for around $175 no more than two or three years ago (including my own). So that's my point of reference.

[at_one]

Right on. I feel like the copy for $300 is a bit overpriced...I offered $250 but they arent budging. I have patience....lol.

[Brian861]

The going rate for THE TALISMAN 1ST/1ST RANDOM HOUSE edition F/F? Thanks!

[Mr. Rabbit Trick]

The going rate for THE TALISMAN 1ST/1ST RANDOM HOUSE edition F/F? Thanks!

$45

[at_one]

What's a CotW S/L going for these days?

[Mr. Rabbit Trick]

What's a CotW S/L going for these days?

With unmarked DJ, $1000. A lot more for the <100 version.

[AKC]

So, what is a <100 worth?

[Randall Flagg]

So, what is a <100 worth?

>100

[Cwalker]

Is $350 a fair price for a new/shrinkwraped Dark Tower Gift Set from a reputable dealer? (meaning i believe that it is not a case of re-wrapping and calling new)

Thanks

[AstroDad]

I bought a s/l of IT off of Ebay recently for BIN of $1000, which seems to be the going rate these days, I believe the last couple I have seen went for 1k-1.1k. Within an hour after purchasing the seller emailed me to tell me he intended to point out in his description a large dent/crease in the traycase but realized he had neglected to and offered to refund my money if I no longer wanted the book. He reiterated that the book itself was in unread condition. The dent/crease is shown in one of the pictures on the auction, but I guess I was excited and felt like someone else was going to snag it before I did and I didn't look closely enough and missed it. The black cover hid it fairly well too, though once you know it is there it is pretty apparent in the picture.

I asked for 24 hours to touch base with CD and see if they had a spare traycase and he agreed, so I shot an email off to try my luck with CD and planned to cancel my order if a new traycase could not be found.

When I checked my email the next morning, I had a PM from Dan confirming they did have one they could sell me along with a message from the seller offering to give me a partial refund of $150 if I didn't cancel. This worked out great for me, I was now paying $850 + the price of the new traycase for it which I felt was a good deal. I hadn't officially ordered the traycase yet (the CD office is infected, so no reply yet from Mindy), but felt confident it would work out.

I received the book yesterday and he failed to mention that someone had written in black marker on the first page (opposite the front cover). It appears to be a price, but I am not certain. It is about 3/4" tall in thick black marker.

So, assuming a good traycase and fine book other than the marking on the first page, how much would that decrease the value? Would you return it, try to get a further discount, or feel like even with the marking it is still a decent copy?

[AstroDad]

Is $350 a fair price for a new/shrinkwraped Dark Tower Gift Set from a reputable dealer? (meaning i believe that it is not a case of re-wrapping and calling new)

Thanks

That seems pretty high to me. I want to say something like that would usually go for closer to $200-$250 but I a curious to see what the experts say.

[AKC]

I bought a s/l of IT off of Ebay recently for BIN of $1000, which seems to be the going rate these days, I believe the last couple I have seen went for 1k-1.1k. Within an hour after purchasing the seller emailed me to tell me he intended to point out in his description a large dent/crease in the traycase but realized he had neglected to and offered to refund my money if I no longer wanted the book. He reiterated that the book itself was in unread condition. The dent/crease is shown in one of the pictures on the auction, but I guess I was excited and felt like someone else was going to snag it before I did and I didn't look closely enough and missed it. The black cover hid it fairly well too, though once you know it is there it is pretty apparent in the picture.

I asked for 24 hours to touch base with CD and see if they had a spare traycase and he agreed, so I shot an email off to try my luck with CD and planned to cancel my order if a new traycase could not be found.

When I checked my email the next morning, I had a PM from Dan confirming they did have one they could sell me along with a message from the seller offering to give me a partial refund of $150 if I didn't cancel. This worked out great for me, I was now paying $850 + the price of the new traycase for it which I felt was a good deal. I hadn't officially ordered the traycase yet (the CD office is infected, so no reply yet from Mindy), but felt confident it would work out.

I received the book yesterday and he failed to mention that someone had written in black marker on the first page (opposite the front cover). It appears to be a price, but I am not certain. It is about 3/4" tall in thick black marker.

So, assuming a good traycase and fine book other than the marking on the first page, how much would that decrease the value? Would you return it, try to get a further discount, or feel like even with the marking it is still a decent copy?

Return it.....you will find another one.

[Room 217 Caretaker]

Is $350 a fair price for a new/shrinkwraped Dark Tower Gift Set from a reputable dealer? (meaning i believe that it is not a case of re-wrapping and calling new)

Thanks

$175-225. The shrinkwrap shouldn't add $150 to the price. You will remove it anyway (or should).

JMO

Mulleins

[Patrick]

I'd probably return it. If not, I'd expect a material discount. He should have had a photo of the writing in his auction.

[Brian861]

I bought a s/l of IT off of Ebay recently for BIN of $1000, which seems to be the going rate these days, I believe the last couple I have seen went for 1k-1.1k. Within an hour after purchasing the seller emailed me to tell me he intended to point out in his description a large dent/crease in the traycase but realized he had neglected to and offered to refund my money if I no longer wanted the book. He reiterated that the book itself was in unread condition. The dent/crease is shown in one of the pictures on the auction, but I guess I was excited and felt like someone else was going to snag it before I did and I didn't look closely enough and missed it. The black cover hid it fairly well too, though once you know it is there it is pretty apparent in the picture.

I asked for 24 hours to touch base with CD and see if they had a spare traycase and he agreed, so I shot an email off to try my luck with CD and planned to cancel my order if a new traycase could not be found.

When I checked my email the next morning, I had a PM from Dan confirming they did have one they could sell me along with a message from the seller offering to give me a partial refund of $150 if I didn't cancel. This worked out great for me, I was now paying $850 + the price of the new traycase for it which I felt was a good deal. I hadn't officially ordered the traycase yet (the CD office is infected, so no reply yet from Mindy), but felt confident it would work out.

I received the book yesterday and he failed to mention that someone had written in black marker on the first page (opposite the front cover). It appears to be a price, but I am not certain. It is about 3/4" tall in thick black marker.

So, assuming a good traycase and fine book other than the marking on the first page, how much would that decrease the value? Would you return it, try to get a further discount, or feel like even with the marking it is still a decent copy?

Return it.....you will find another one.

Agreed. I personally hate writing/markings of any nature in a book that shouldn't be there and especially undisclosed. Deal breaker.

[bdwyer19]

I bought a s/l of IT off of Ebay recently for BIN of $1000, which seems to be the going rate these days, I believe the last couple I have seen went for 1k-1.1k. Within an hour after purchasing the seller emailed me to tell me he intended to point out in his description a large dent/crease in the traycase but realized he had neglected to and offered to refund my money if I no longer wanted the book. He reiterated that the book itself was in unread condition. The dent/crease is shown in one of the pictures on the auction, but I guess I was excited and felt like someone else was going to snag it before I did and I didn't look closely enough and missed it. The black cover hid it fairly well too, though once you know it is there it is pretty apparent in the picture.

I asked for 24 hours to touch base with CD and see if they had a spare traycase and he agreed, so I shot an email off to try my luck with CD and planned to cancel my order if a new traycase could not be found.

When I checked my email the next morning, I had a PM from Dan confirming they did have one they could sell me along with a message from the seller offering to give me a partial refund of $150 if I didn't cancel. This worked out great for me, I was now paying $850 + the price of the new traycase for it which I felt was a good deal. I hadn't officially ordered the traycase yet (the CD office is infected, so no reply yet from Mindy), but felt confident it would work out.

I received the book yesterday and he failed to mention that someone had written in black marker on the first page (opposite the front cover). It appears to be a price, but I am not certain. It is about 3/4" tall in thick black marker.

So, assuming a good traycase and fine book other than the marking on the first page, how much would that decrease the value? Would you return it, try to get a further discount, or feel like even with the marking it is still a decent copy?

So, he sold it, then realized he neglected to disclose something. You received it, and realized he forgot to disclose another thing. Not cool! I agree with the others, you will find another one in Fine condition for a reasonable price.

[AstroDad]

I bought a s/l of IT off of Ebay recently for BIN of $1000, which seems to be the going rate these days, I believe the last couple I have seen went for 1k-1.1k. Within an hour after purchasing the seller emailed me to tell me he intended to point out in his description a large dent/crease in the traycase but realized he had neglected to and offered to refund my money if I no longer wanted the book. He reiterated that the book itself was in unread condition. The dent/crease is shown in one of the pictures on the auction, but I guess I was excited and felt like someone else was going to snag it before I did and I didn't look closely enough and missed it. The black cover hid it fairly well too, though once you know it is there it is pretty apparent in the picture.

I asked for 24 hours to touch base with CD and see if they had a spare traycase and he agreed, so I shot an email off to try my luck with CD and planned to cancel my order if a new traycase could not be found.

When I checked my email the next morning, I had a PM from Dan confirming they did have one they could sell me along with a message from the seller offering to give me a partial refund of $150 if I didn't cancel. This worked out great for me, I was now paying $850 + the price of the new traycase for it which I felt was a good deal. I hadn't officially ordered the traycase yet (the CD office is infected, so no reply yet from Mindy), but felt confident it would work out.

I received the book yesterday and he failed to mention that someone had written in black marker on the first page (opposite the front cover). It appears to be a price, but I am not certain. It is about 3/4" tall in thick black marker.

So, assuming a good traycase and fine book other than the marking on the first page, how much would that decrease the value? Would you return it, try to get a further discount, or feel like even with the marking it is still a decent copy?

So, he sold it, then realized he neglected to disclose something. You received it, and realized he forgot to disclose another thing. Not cool! I agree with the others, you will find another one in Fine condition for a reasonable price.

He did disclose in the auction that this was the first book he has ever sold...so I was wary.

I know I should return it, this was the one book I told myself I would buy if it became available...hard to let go.

Any guesses as to how much it affects the actual value? I know it varies collector to collector, but ballpark? I could just remove the page altogether very carefully! lol

[carlosdetweiller]

Send it back. You will never be completely happy with it. You will always know the defects are there and they will bug you more and more as time goes by.

Also, when you find a better one to replace it you will have a very hard time trying to sell this one.

Get rid of it now.