Originally Posted by
wizardsrainbow
Well, food for thought with all these posts....first off, I will correct listing to day Carrie Artist Edition (not Gift edition). It's hard to keep straight what is Gift, Artist, Deluxe etc.
It is actually the Gift Edition (not Artist Edition)
I agree it can be hard to keep straight. Generally, it seems fairly consistent that signed by the Artist (and not the author) = Artist Edition, but the fact that the Cemetery Artist edition is numbered is what I think throws things off in our minds. It FEELS like a S/L with the nice Traycases, etc. So the slipcased edition feels like an Artist edition.
Ignoring the nicer features than most Artist Editions CD is giving us with this series, I eel like the standard is (or should be):
Nicer edition than trade, limited run, but not signed by anyone = Gift Edition
Limited run signed by artist, but not author = Artist Edition
More limited run signed by Author, may also be signed by Artist = S/L Edition