2012 List
2013 List
2014 List
2015 List

2016
1. Feverborn - Karen Marie Moning
2. The Dirt on Ninth Grave - Darynda Jones
3. The Fox and the Star - Coralie Bickford-Smith
4. The Quick - Lauren Owen
5. Prince of Fools - Mark Lawrence
6. Skin - Patrick Logan
7. Armada - Ernest Cline
8. Morning Star - Pierce Brown
9. The Liar's Key - Mark Lawrence
10. The Beast - JR Ward
11. Neverwhere - Neil Gaiman
12. Sleeping Giants- Sylvain Neuvel
13. The Fireman - Joe Hill
14. The Owl Killers - Karen Maitland
15. End of Watch - Stephen King
16. The Curse of Tenth Grave - Darynda Jones
17. The Wheel of Osheim - Mark Lawrence
18. The City of Mirrors - Justin Cronin
19. Hex - Thomas Olde Heuvelt
20. The Trees - Ali Shaw
21. The Last Unicorn: The Lost Version - Peter S. Beagle
22. Dark Matter - Blake Crouch
23. Six Scary Stories
24. Summerlong - Peter S. Beagle
25. Kushiel's Dart - Jacqueline Carey