Designated in blue are the bracket runners-up; designated in green are the bracket winners; designated in maroon are the wildcards (to be determined at the end of Round 1). "FAS" stands for "Final Average Score", an average of all received votes.

Bracket 1: opened January 12
Carrie: rated 4 with 13 votes (35.14%) (FAS 3.676470588)
'Salem's Lot: rated 5 with 21 votes (53.85%) (FAS 4.378378378)
Rage: rated 4 with 13 votes (34.21%) (FAS 3.555555556)
The Shining: rated 5 with 24 votes (61.54%) (FAS 4.611111111)
Night Shift: rated 5 with 15 votes (42.86%) (FAS 4.250000000)

Bracket 2: opened January 14
The Stand: rated 5 with 35 votes (77.78%) (FAS 4.790697674)
The Dead Zone: rated 5 with 15 votes (40.54%) (FAS 4.166666667)
The Long Walk: rated 5 with 20 votes (58.82%) (FAS 4.586206897)
Firestarter: rated 4 with 17 votes (53.13%) (FAS 4.111111111)
Cujo: rated 4 with 15 votes (41.67%) (FAS 3.967741935)

Bracket 3: opened January 19
Roadwork: rated NR with 11 votes (36.67%) - highest rating 5 with 7 votes (23.33%) (FAS 3.894736842)
The Running Man: rated 4 with 15 votes (42.86%) (FAS 3.964285714)
The Dark Tower: The Gunslinger: rated 5 with 27 votes (65.85%) (FAS 4.439024390)
Different Seasons: rated 5 with 19 votes (54.29%) (FAS 4.500000000)
Christine: rated 5 with 12 votes (34.29%) (FAS 4.148148148)

Bracket 4: opened January 21
Pet Sematary: rated 5 with 17 votes (53.13%) (FAS 4.500000000)
Cycle of the Werewolf: rated NR with 9 votes (31.03%) - highest rating 3 with 8 votes (27.59%) (FAS 3.700000000)
The Talisman: rated 5 with 20 votes (52.63%) (FAS 4.454545455)
Thinner: rated 4 with 12 votes (34.29%) (FAS 3.851851852)
Skeleton Crew: rated 5 with 11 votes (40.74%) (FAS 4.192307692)

Bracket 5: opened January 27
It: rated 5 with 23 votes (69.70%) (FAS 4.733333333)
The Eyes of the Dragon: rated 5 with 11 votes (35.48%) (FAS 3.962962963)
The Dark Tower II: The Drawing of the Three: rated 5 with 27 votes (71.05%) (FAS 4.631578947)
Misery: rated 5 with 18 votes (60.00%) (FAS 4.600000000)
The Tommyknockers: rated 4 with 11 votes (35.48%) (FAS 3.560000000)

Bracket 6: opened January 31
The Dark Half: rating tied 5-4 with 7 votes (25.93%) (FAS 3.857142857)
Four Past Midnight: rated 4 with 10 votes (40.00%) (FAS 4.300000000)
The Dark Tower III: The Waste Lands: rated 5 with 27 votes (75.00%) (FAS 4.750000000)
Needful Things: rated 5 with 11 votes (39.29%) (FAS 4.380952381)
Gerald's Game: rated 1 with 8 votes (28.57%) (FAS 2.680000000)

Bracket 7: opened February 2
Dolores Claiborne: rated 4 with 10 votes (40.00%) (FAS 3.705882353)
Nightmares & Dreamscapes: rated 5 with 10 votes (40.00%) (FAS 4.217391304)
Insomnia: rated 5 with 13 votes (44.83%) (FAS 4.076923077)
Rose Madder: rated 3 with 9 votes (32.14%) (FAS 3.636363636)
The Green Mile: rated 5 with 20 votes (71.43%) (FAS 4.720000000)

Bracket 8: opened February 4
Desperation: rated 5 with 12 votes (42.86%) (FAS 4.040000000)
The Regulators: rated 3 with 8 votes (25.00%) (FAS 3.440000000)
The Dark Tower IV: Wizard and Glass: rated 5 with 18 votes (48.65%) (FAS 4.222222222)
Bag of Bones: rated 5 with 9 votes (34.62%) (FAS 4.000000000)
Storm of the Century: rated NR with 15 votes (53.57%) - highest rating 3 with 6 votes (21.43%) (FAS 3.384615385)

Bracket 9: opened February 9
The Girl Who Loved Tom Gordon: rated 3 with 8 votes (25.00%) (FAS 3.240000000)
Hearts in Atlantis: rated 4 with 10 votes (35.71%) (FAS 4.125000000)
On Writing: rated 5 with 8 votes (30.77%) (FAS 3.950000000)
Dreamcatcher: rated 4 with 9 votes (34.62%) (FAS 3.608695652)
Black House: rated 5 with 11 votes (37.93%) (FAS 4.272727273)

Bracket 10: opened February 11
Everything's Eventual: rated 4 with 12 votes (40.00%) (FAS 4.153846154)
From a Buick 8: rated NR with 9 votes (28.13%) - highest rating 3 with 7 votes (21.88%) (FAS 3.217391304)
The Dark Tower V: Wolves of the Calla: rated 5 with 19 votes (54.29%) (FAS 4.441176471)
The Dark Tower VI: Song of Susannah: rated 4 with 11 votes (31.43%) (FAS 3.764705882)
The Dark Tower VII: The Dark Tower: rated 5 with 22 votes (59.46%) (FAS 4.428571429)

Bracket 11: opened February 16
The Colorado Kid: rated NR with 15 votes (42.86%) - highest rating 3 with 7 votes (20.00%) (FAS 3.550000000)
Cell: rated 4 with 15 votes (42.86%) (FAS 4.133333333)
Lisey's Story: rated NR with 12 votes (35.29%) - highest rating tied 5-2-1 with 5 votes (14.71%) (FAS 2.909090909)
Blaze: rated NR with 11 votes (31.43%) - highest rating tied 4-3 with 9 votes (25.71%) (FAS 3.625000000)
Duma Key: rated 5 with 15 votes (42.86%) (FAS 4.461538462)

Bracket 12: opened February 18
Just After Sunset: rated NR with 10 votes (28.57%) - highest rating 3 with 9 votes (25.71%) (FAS 3.320000000)
Under the Dome: rated 4 with 11 votes (30.56%) (FAS 3.962962963)
Blockade Billy: rated NR with 11 votes (34.38%) - highest rating 4 with 7 votes (21.88%) (FAS 3.000000000)
Full Dark, No Stars: rated 4 with 15 votes (45.45%) (FAS 3.923076923)
11/22/63: rated 5 with 17 votes (47.22%) (FAS 4.695652174)