Search:

Type: Posts; User: pathoftheturtle

Search: Search took 0.05 seconds.

  1. Sticky: Poll: That old ka-mai? Don't make me laugh. But,...

    That old ka-mai? Don't make me laugh.

    But, look, my position hasn't changed: I'm glad that both versions exist. I can talk about my personal preferences, but I don't really understand the...
  2. Sticky: Poll: Yes, I've read that introduction at least a dozen...

    No.[/QUOTE]

    For me it depends on who you are talking to. If King feels it's important to him that his series, his Great Work, be consistent then it's important for him and I can see why. I think...
  3. Sticky: Poll: I'm not so sure. Is consistency really so...

    I'm not so sure. Is consistency really so important in literature, anyway? The original was an ambiguous romantic epic, like the poem. Does comicbook-style continuity necessarily improve that?
  4. Sticky: Poll: This debate reminds me of another one from way...

    This debate reminds me of another one from way back when: America elects a King
  5. Sticky: Poll: :lol:

    :lol:
  6. Sticky: Poll: Here, I will just agree that you do make a pretty...

    Here, I will just agree that you do make a pretty good point about the revised. Your summation of the nature of the rest of the series was striking enough to me, though, that I've commented futher...
  7. Sticky: Poll: Roland had already travelled far from Gilead to...

    Yes, if the sea was named the Western Sea that doesn't have to mean it was west of Gilead.[/QUOTE]Roland had already travelled far from Gilead to reach the Mohaine... going westward all the time. ...
  8. Sticky: Poll: Right. I think that what you're saying there,...

    Right. I think that what you're saying there, Cgf, suggests a better answer to the following than the one quoted from sj below:
    I'm curious what he thinks he needs to edit/rewrite.[/quote] i think...
  9. Sticky: Poll: "Original or Revised, if you HAD to choose"

    I'm just glad that I DON'T have to choose. I can see the pros and cons of each, and very much like having both.
  10. Sticky: Poll: That's nothing. How about this:Lud is New York...

    Man, that bugged me SO much that my search for a map of the world of The Dark Tower is what brought me to this forum in the first place. It annoyed the heck out of me and no matter how much I told...
Results 1 to 10 of 10