Round 3, Group A

Printable View

11-05-2013 02:13 AM
Jean

Round 3, Group A

Here we define the order of the novels with 4 secondings each at positions 48 to 68.

Vote all your favorites.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...hap01-1762.jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...arlotteWeb.png http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...son_rocher.jpg

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...ver_serial.jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...t_Dune_1st.jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...ghtclubcvr.jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...tion_gnome.jpg
11-05-2013 04:44 AM
pathoftheturtle

Oh... they're getting harder...
11-05-2013 07:03 AM
mae

Dumbass all the way.
11-05-2013 01:08 PM
Mattrick

Come on Candide! One of my favourites, can read it once a year.
11-06-2013 05:46 AM
Jean

bears anticipate tons of tiebreakers in this round
11-06-2013 06:11 AM
Darkthoughts

Dune. I can't say i enjoyed the subsequent books as much, but Dune is to sci-fi what LotR is to fantasy.
11-06-2013 06:23 AM
Jean

http://i91.photobucket.com/albums/k2.../bear_hmmm.gif
11-06-2013 01:33 PM
Merlin1958

Quote:

Originally Posted by Darkthoughts

Dune. I can't say i enjoyed the subsequent books as much, but Dune is to sci-fi what LotR is to fantasy.

I loved "Dune" as well, but I don't think i go so far as to say that. "Foundation" was a great story as well. There is a lot of Sci-fi that compares where there is little to compete with LOTR in fantasy. IMHO
11-07-2013 03:22 AM
Darkthoughts

I don't mean in terms of how good a story it is, but in terms of original concept and popularity/notoriety. Dune, as with LotR, is one of those books that almost everyone knows whether they like the genre or not.
11-09-2013 01:55 PM
mae

Need more votes for Monte Cristo! This should've been in the Top 5.
11-09-2013 03:18 PM
Merlin1958

Quote:

Originally Posted by Darkthoughts

I don't mean in terms of how good a story it is, but in terms of original concept and popularity/notoriety. Dune, as with LotR, is one of those books that almost everyone knows whether they like the genre or not.

I think I understand what you're saying, but LOTR virtually founded the fantasy genre or at least set the ground work for all that followed, while "Dune" is one of many, even though it is genuinely "out there" and original as far as the setting/story goes. Take Jule Verne' works for example, they would seem closer to the "LOTR" than Dune. BTW, I just say this because I do enjoy a discussion and the learning associated with it. Of course, it may just be a "moot" point as all are entitled to their own opinions. Feeling "talky" today!! LOL

Quote:

Originally Posted by pablo

Need more votes for Monte Cristo! This should've been in the Top 5.

Agreed
11-10-2013 12:29 PM
Jean

I tend to agree with Bill on the subject of Dune and sci-fi. Not only Jules Verne or H.G.Wells, but Symak, Kuttner, Asimov, Sheckley, Stanisław Lem - they all pre-date Dune, and they are truly the great ones.

As far as Monte Cristo is concerned, much as I love this novel, I believe the middle of the list is where it should be.

***

this poll closes in 48 hours
11-10-2013 04:54 PM
Merlin1958

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jean

I tend to agree with Bill on the subject of Dune and sci-fi. Not only Jules Verne or H.G.Wells, but Symak, Kuttner, Asimov, Sheckley, Stanisław Lem - they all pre-date Dune, and they are truly the great ones.

As far as Monte Cristo is concerned, much as I love this novel, I believe the middle of the list is where it should be.

***

this poll closes in 48 hours

Wow!! Cool, Bears!! That's THREE "Post - agrees" I have received in one week. What the hell is going on? Am I "changing" or, is everyone else "seeing the light"? LOL OK, guess I may be changing for the better!! LOL

Spoiler:

Just "fooling about, folks"!!! LOL
11-10-2013 07:52 PM
BROWNINGS CHILDE

I had to make myself finish Count of Monte Cristo.
11-11-2013 12:06 AM
mae

Quote:

Originally Posted by BROWNINGS CHILDE

I had to make myself finish Count of Monte Cristo.

Maybe because you were reading a bad translation. There's a perfect translation by Robin Buss published by Penguin in 2003.
11-11-2013 05:11 PM
BROWNINGS CHILDE

Thanks Pablo. I might try it again, eventually, but there is so much to read and so little time that I feel I have to reserve rereads to my absolute favorites anymore.
11-13-2013 01:17 AM
Jean

or better reserve this particular reread till you can read it in the original! it's really really good

***

the poll is closed now. The tiebreakers will appear later today