Aaron
01-04-2009, 11:43 AM
Hey everyone!
Thanks so much to everyone who participated in our voting for Round 1 of the Constant Reader Awards. From the original list of sixty, we have narrowed it down to thirty books that will now be graded in Round 2.
The voting is a bit different in this round, so I wanted to break it down for everyone so that we have minimal confusion.
In Round 2 we will grading each book in three different areas. These are Strength of Plot, Character Development, and Quality of the Story's Ending. The collections and non-fiction works that are graded in this round will be graded under areas more applicable to the medium. The voting basics are the same for all of the books, though.
Since there are three different areas to be voted in this time, these polls will allow voters to select more than one option. This is tricky, though, because it does allow some room for user error. It is imperative that voters choose only one grade (A, B, or C) for each area being graded. Please see the example below:
http://www.thedarktower.org/gallery/data/500/duma1.JPG
This is an example of a valid "ballot". The voter chose to give the book a "B" in Strength of Plot, an "A" in Character Development, and a "C" in Quality of Ending. One from each area. Now if the voter chose instead to give it "A"s in all three areas, that will also be valid. The letter grades given do not matter, only that there is just one for each area.
Here are two examples of incorrect/invalid ballots:
http://www.thedarktower.org/gallery/data/500/duma2.JPG http://www.thedarktower.org/gallery/data/500/duma3.JPG
In the first example, we see that the voter selected both "A" and "B" in the Strength of Plot area, and did the same in the Quality of Ending area. Since there is no way of discerning what the voter's intended vote was, the ballot is invalid and none of the voter's votes will count.
The second example there is an illustration of someone who is just trying to piss me off. You'll notice that all ten fields are selected, and we obviously wouldn't count any of this person's votes.
If you select more than one grade in an area by mistake, we can make a correction for you, but want to keep this to a bare minimum, as it is time-consuming. If this does occur, please PM me with your correct votes and I'll take care of it.
The letter grades in this round correspond with numeric values that will be averaged, in the same way that they were for Round 1. When the average score for each grading area is compiled, those scores will then be averaged to give the book an overall average grade. These grades will be added to the scores each book earned in Round 1.
Once all books have been graded and their Round 2 score has been added in, the top 10 scoring books will move on to Round 3, the Face-Off Round.
Feel free to discuss this or ask questions in this thread, and thanks again to everyone for your participation.
Thanks so much to everyone who participated in our voting for Round 1 of the Constant Reader Awards. From the original list of sixty, we have narrowed it down to thirty books that will now be graded in Round 2.
The voting is a bit different in this round, so I wanted to break it down for everyone so that we have minimal confusion.
In Round 2 we will grading each book in three different areas. These are Strength of Plot, Character Development, and Quality of the Story's Ending. The collections and non-fiction works that are graded in this round will be graded under areas more applicable to the medium. The voting basics are the same for all of the books, though.
Since there are three different areas to be voted in this time, these polls will allow voters to select more than one option. This is tricky, though, because it does allow some room for user error. It is imperative that voters choose only one grade (A, B, or C) for each area being graded. Please see the example below:
http://www.thedarktower.org/gallery/data/500/duma1.JPG
This is an example of a valid "ballot". The voter chose to give the book a "B" in Strength of Plot, an "A" in Character Development, and a "C" in Quality of Ending. One from each area. Now if the voter chose instead to give it "A"s in all three areas, that will also be valid. The letter grades given do not matter, only that there is just one for each area.
Here are two examples of incorrect/invalid ballots:
http://www.thedarktower.org/gallery/data/500/duma2.JPG http://www.thedarktower.org/gallery/data/500/duma3.JPG
In the first example, we see that the voter selected both "A" and "B" in the Strength of Plot area, and did the same in the Quality of Ending area. Since there is no way of discerning what the voter's intended vote was, the ballot is invalid and none of the voter's votes will count.
The second example there is an illustration of someone who is just trying to piss me off. You'll notice that all ten fields are selected, and we obviously wouldn't count any of this person's votes.
If you select more than one grade in an area by mistake, we can make a correction for you, but want to keep this to a bare minimum, as it is time-consuming. If this does occur, please PM me with your correct votes and I'll take care of it.
The letter grades in this round correspond with numeric values that will be averaged, in the same way that they were for Round 1. When the average score for each grading area is compiled, those scores will then be averaged to give the book an overall average grade. These grades will be added to the scores each book earned in Round 1.
Once all books have been graded and their Round 2 score has been added in, the top 10 scoring books will move on to Round 3, the Face-Off Round.
Feel free to discuss this or ask questions in this thread, and thanks again to everyone for your participation.